Administration

Investigative documents related to fatal officer-involved shooting cases

The office of Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost is committed to post-investigation transparency in all officer-involved critical incidents (OICI). This means public access to records after the investigating agency has completed its investigation – a process that forms the basis for any legal action stemming from the incident – and either a prosecutor or grand jury has decided not to indict the case, or the case is indicted and has been prosecuted in court.

This site archives case files from fatal officer-involved shooting incidents in which the Bureau of Criminal Investigation was the primary investigator and/or the Attorney General’s Special Prosecution Section presented the case to a grand jury.

Below are documents and other information for OICI cases that have been completed.

Note that any document redactions or video modifications were made to meet the requirements of Ohio’s Sunshine Laws.

Investigative documents

  • Assistance with BCI Case 2023-2730
  • Attachment List_Redacted
  • Binder Contents_Redacted
  • Body Camera Review of Officer Robert Giovanni
  • Case Opening
  • Autopsy Attended Report
  • Body Camera Review of Involved Officer
  • Case Cover Sheet_Redacted
  • Case Overview_Redacted
  • Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner Trace Evidence Notification
  • EMS Run Report Redacted
  • Evidence Photography/Packaging
  • Evidence Transport
  • Evidence Transported to BCI
  • Evidence-from-Ohio-Bureau-of-Criminal-Investigation-Hootman-Larry
  • Evidence-from-SA-Larry-Hootman
  • Evidence-List_Redacted
  • Evidence-Receipt-from-Autopsy
  • File-Details_Redacted
  • File-List_Redacted
  • Information Obtained for Ricco Acevedo
  • Interview with Elizabeth Cuevas
  • Interview with Involved Officer
  • Interview with Jeff Dobson
  • Interview with Jen Schrenckengost
  • Interview with Julie Woods
  • Interview with Officer Robert Giovanni
  • Interview with Tom Allison
  • Interview with YPD Involved
  • Interview-YPD-Officer-Hilliard
  • Involved Officer Contact and Documentation
  • Item-Details_Redacted
  • L-M-Mahoning-Cty-Acceptance-Letter_Redacted
  • Matter-Notes_Redacted
  • Meeting with Prosecutor
  • Neighborhood Canvass Interview with Dani Jo Morrison
  • Neighborhood Canvass Interview with Kyle Thomas Holes
  • Neighborhood Canvass Interview with Shayla Madison-Crockett
  • OFC Hilliard Body Camera Review
  • Officer-Involved-Critical-Incident-(S)-Ricco-Acevedo
  • Party-Details_Redacted
  • Party-List_Redacted
  • Records-Received-Review-of-Records
  • Records-Received-Review-of-Records-CCCO-Autopsy
  • Redactions Applied
  • Reference-Item-List_Redacted
  • Register 360 Report
  • Report-List_Redacted
  • Request-Assistance-of-the-Special-Prosecutions-Section_Redacted
  • Review of Autopsy Records
  • Review of Involved Officer Records
  • Review of YPD Dispatch CAD Report
  • Review of YPD Radio Traffic
  • Review of YPD Use of Force Policy
  • Scene Processing
  • Subject-Overview_Redacted
  • Witness Officers Contact and Documentation
  • Prosecutor Summary Redacted
  • YPD-Body-Camera-Review
  • YPD-OFC-Giovanni-Body-Camera-Review
  • Investigative photos

  • Evidence Photographs 1
  • Evidence Photographs 2
  • Evidence Photographs 3
  • Evidence Photographs 4
  • Evidence Photographs 5
  • Evidence Photographs 6
  • Evidence Photographs 7
  • Evidence Photographs 8
  • Evidence Photographs 9
  • Redacted Evidence Photographs
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Investigative documents

  • Autopsy Examination
  • Case Open
  • Consent to Search Report
  • Crime Scene Examination
  • Evidence Transfer
  • Interview of Officer Anthony Poppe
  • Interview of Officer Daniel Speckman
  • Interview of Officer Darrell Etgen
  • Interview of Officer Dave Powell
  • Interview of Officer Jacob Little
  • Interview of Officer Justin Rice
  • Interview of Officer Kevin Wynk
  • Interview of Officer Lance Brunswick
  • Interview of Officer Patrick Cupp
  • Interview with Dispatcher Nathan Cupp
  • Interview with EMT Aaron Schott
  • Interview with Hannah Pawelski
  • Interview with Paramedic Aaron Beougher
  • Interview with Paramedic Brian Davis
  • Interview with Paramedic Mitch Leugers
  • Letters from Clarence Saalman
  • Medical Documents Review for Corey Andrew
  • Medical Records Review for Officer Justin Rice
  • OOICI Video Review
  • Prosecutor Summary
  • Receipt of Celina PD and Mercer County Sheriff's Office Reports
  • Receipt of Celina PD Use of Force Policy
  • Redactions Made
  • Review of Officer Powell's Training Records
  • Review of Officer Powell's Personnel File
  • Review of Officer Rice's Personnel File
  • Review of Officer Rice's Training Records
  • Review of Police Reports from Assisting Agencies
  • Review of Radio Traffic
  • Search Warrant of Trailblazer
  • Investigative photos

  • Evidence Photographs 1
  • Evidence Photographs 2
  • Evidence Photographs 3
  • Evidence Photographs 4
  • Evidence Photographs 5
  • Evidence Photographs 6
  • Evidence Photographs 7
  • Evidence Photographs 8
  • Evidence Photographs 9
  • Evidence Photographs 10
  • Evidence Photographs 11
  • Evidence Photographs 12
  • Evidence Photographs 13
  • Evidence Photographs 14
  • Redacted Evidence Photographs
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Investigative documents

  • Case Opening
  • Documents Received and Photographs Taken
  • Initial Response
  • Interview of Annette Trowbridge
  • Interview of Dr. Mark Harris
  • Interview of Involved Officer 2
  • Interview of Involved Officer 3
  • Interview of Involved Sergeant 1
  • Interview of Involved Staff Brandon Mason
  • Interview of Involved Staff Jeffrey Rubel
  • Interview of Involved Staff Juan Crespo
  • Interview of Jessica Herman
  • Interview of Kristine Novick
  • Interview of Rebecca Thompson
  • Interview of Robert Tyler Cogar
  • Prosecutor Summary
  • Redactions Made
  • Review of Autopsy Report
  • Review of CAD Report
  • Review of Dispatch Related Information
  • Review of EMS Report
  • Review of Intelligence Information
  • Review of Licensing and Intelligence Information
  • Review of OPOTC Records of Involved Officer 2
  • Review of OPOTC Records of Involved Officer 3
  • Review of OPOTC Records of Involved Sergeant 1
  • Review of Personnel File and Training Records of Involved Officer 2
  • Review of Personnel File and Training Records of Involved Officer 3
  • Review of Personnel File and Training Records of Involved Sergeant 1
  • Review of Personnel File of Brandon Mason
  • Review of Personnel File of Jeffrey Rubel
  • Review of Personnel File of Juan Crespo
  • Review of Strongsville Police Department CAD Report
  • Review of Surveillance Camera Footage
  • Review of Written Statements
  • Search Warrant Obtained
  • Use of Force Policy Received
  • Investigative photos

  • Evidence Photographs
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Investigative documents

  • 22CR0109 Redacted
  • Acceptance Paperwork Filed
  • Audit Log for Axon Body 3 Video X60A2590C
  • Audit Log for Axon Body 3 Video X60A2632A
  • Audit Log for Axon Body 3 Video X60A20957
  • Audit Log for Axon Fleet 3 Dual View Camera Video 1408
  • Audit Log for Jisco West Barricaded Subject JCSO Shooting
  • Autopsy and Toxicology Review
  • Autopsy Evidence
  • Body Worn Camera Review
  • Booking Records
  • Communications Log
  • Death Certificate
  • Email to Attorney Letter
  • Interview with Deputy Jesse Reynolds
  • Interview with Deputy Leif Smith
  • Interview with Deputy Nick Spangler
  • Interview with Deputy Scott Conley
  • Interview with Mellisa Graham
  • Interview with Officer
  • Interview with Paul Swain and Stephenie Fiorini
  • Interview with Probation Officer Christina Edwards
  • Interview with Probation Officer Wesley Skaggs
  • Interview with Sgt. Jason Wilson
  • Interview with Shalee Fiorini and Joseph Malone
  • Interview with Shawn Norman
  • Interview with Sheriff Tedd Frazier
  • Interview with Trooper Brice Vickers
  • Interview with Trooper Marlin Folden
  • Interview with Trooper Sherry Wells
  • Location History 1
  • Location History 2
  • Officer Admin Leave Letter
  • Officer Appointment of Deputy Sheriff
  • Officer Appointments
  • Officer Clandestine Lab Safety Recertification
  • Officer Evaluation Letter
  • Officer Personnel File Review
  • Officer Psych Eval
  • Officer Qualifications
  • Officer Range Proficiency
  • Officer Training
  • Officer Water Rescue
  • Processing of Crime Scene
  • Processing of Officer Documentation
  • Prosecutors Summary
  • Redactions Made
  • Search Warrant
  • Table of Contents
  • Witness Statement from Wesley Skaggs
  • Investigative photos

  • Crime Scene Photographs
  • Other Photographs
  • Photograph Evidence 1
  • Photograph Evidence 2
  • Photograph Evidence 3
  • Photograph Evidence 4
  • Photograph Evidence 5
  • Photograph Evidence 6
  • Photograph Evidence 7
  • Photograph Evidence 8
  • Photograph Evidence 9
  • Redacted Photograph Evidence
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Case file regarding the fatal officer-involved shooting involving Vincent Belmonte and law enforcement officers from the East Cleveland Police Department. The investigation was conducted by the Bureau of Criminal Investigation and was presented by an Ohio Attorney General’s Office special prosecutor to a Cuyahoga County grand jury on October 21, 2021. The grand jury issued a no-bill indictment in the case, declining to indict the law enforcement officers involved in the case.

    Main report

  • Request for Assistance, Acceptance, and Appointment of Special Prosecutor
  • Case Redactions
  • Investigative documents

    Investigative videos

    Investigative audios

    Investigative photos

    Investigative documents

  • 1st Police Report by Officer Aspacher
  • 1st Police Report Prior Contact
  • Atrium Middletown Hospital Emergency Room
  • Autopsy of Dustin Booth
  • Ballistic Report
  • BCI Request for Assistance Letter
  • Body Camera Review
  • CAD Report
  • Call Log on 2-1-2022
  • Call Log on 2-9-2022
  • Call Log on-2-11-2022
  • Case Opening
  • CCU Analysis Report
  • Cell Phone Search Warrant
  • Collection of Autopsy Evidence
  • Consent to Search
  • Crime Scene Access Log
  • Crime Scene Processing of Residence
  • Dayton News Booth Family Statement
  • Evidence Receipt from Butler County Prosecutor's Office
  • Evidence Receipt from Kevin Wagner
  • Evidence Receipt from Scene 1
  • Evidence Receipt from Scene 2
  • Evidence Receipt to Butler County Prosecutor's Office
  • Field Report
  • Fire Department Run Report
  • Follow-up Interview with Justin Duh
  • Interview of Detective Aaron Ledford
  • Interview of Detective Matthew Parker
  • Interview of Officer Austin Whitt
  • Interview of Officer Charles Malott
  • Interview of Officer Fred Doughman
  • Interview of Officer Matthew Buddo
  • Interview of Officer Micah Day
  • Interview of Officer Michelle Berling
  • Interview of Officer Skylar Halsey
  • Interview of Sergeant Caleb Payne
  • Interview of Sergeant Chad Caudill
  • Interview of Sergeant Robert Eddie Myers
  • Interview with Brandi Booth
  • Interview with Eliza Miller
  • Interview with Jonathan Janowski
  • Interview with Justin Duh
  • Monroe Police Department Use of Force Policy
  • Notice of Criminal Investigations of Officer Austin Whitt
  • Notice of Criminal Investigations of Officer Fred Doughman
  • Notice of Criminal Investigations of Officer Micah Day
  • Notice of Criminal Investigations of Officer Skylar Halsey
  • Notice of Criminal Investigations of Sergeant Caleb Payne
  • Officers Qualification Records
  • Patrol BWC Fleet Revised Cameras
  • Processing of Involved Officers
  • Prosecutor Summary
  • Receipt of Document Review and Records Received
  • Receipt of Records Received
  • Receipt of Scene 3 Evidence Log
  • Records Received from Justin Duh's Attorney
  • Redactions Made
  • Scene Processing of SR63 and New Garver Rd
  • Screenshot of Text between Brandi Booth and Justin Duh
  • Search Warrant of 120 Bluegrass Lane
  • Diagrams

  • Diagram of Shooting Location
  • Diagram of SR63
  • Diagram from Eliza Miller
  • Diagram from Jonathan Janowski
  • Investigative photos

  • Photos
  • Investigative videos

    Investigative audios

    Case file regarding the officer-involved shooting involving Ma’Khia Bryant and law enforcement officers from the Columbus Division of Police on April 20, 2021. The investigation was conducted by the Bureau of Criminal Investigation and referred to the Franklin County Prosecutor’s Office on July 7, 2021. A Franklin County grand jury issued a no-bill in the case, declining to indict the officers involved, on March 11, 2022.

    Statement

    Attorney General Dave Yost Releases Investigative Documents on Ma'Khia Bryant Shooting

    Investigative documents

  • 3160 Legion Lane Surveillance Video Review
  • 3171 Legion Lane Crime Scene Processing
  • 3160 Legion Lane Video Surveillance
  • 3171 Legion Lane Ring Preservation Letter
  • 3171 Legion Lane Surveillance Video Review
  • ADT Preservation Acknowledgement Email Copy
  • ADT Preservation Letter for 3171 Legion Lane
  • Angela Moore Consent for Phone
  • AT&T Subpoena 614-586-6607
  • AT&T Subpoena 614-639-9459
  • AT&T Subpoena 678-579-6935
  • Attempt Phone Contact with Jeanene Hammonds
  • Attempt to Contact Jeanene Hammonds
  • BWC Video Review
  • CAD Radio Traffic Recording Review
  • Case Cover Sheet
  • CCU Investigative Report
  • Collection of Autopsy Evidence
  • Contact from CPD
  • CPD Crime Scene Access Log
  • Email Sending Ring Preservation Letter
  • Evidence Log for Case #2021-0957 Scene 1
  • Evidence Log for Case #2021-0957 Scene 2
  • Evidence List
  • Evidence Return to Shai-onta Craig and Tionna Bonner
  • Executed ADT Warrant Affidavit and Return
  • Executed Ring Warrant Affidavit and Return
  • FCCO Evidence Log
  • FCCS Communication Discrepancy
  • FCCS Discrepancy Communication Email Copy
  • FCCS Email Attachment
  • Firearms Lab Report Received and Reviewed
  • Franklin County Children Services Records
  • Initial Autopsy Report for Ma'Khia Bryant
  • Initial Scene Response
  • Interview with Angela Moore
  • Interview with Chris Mitchell
  • Interview with Darlene Carter-Palm
  • Interview with James Martin
  • Interview with Ja'niah Bryant
  • Interview with Jhamia Towler
  • Interview with John Ballard
  • Interview with Kennedy Watkins
  • Interview with Myron Hammonds
  • Interview with Officer Eric Channel
  • Interview with Officer Nicholas Reardon
  • Interview with Officer Serge Akpalo
  • Interview with Shai-onta Craig
  • Interview with Tionna Bonner
  • Jeanene Hammonds Message on Angela Moore's Phone
  • Lab Evidence Submission Sheet
  • Neighborhood Canvass
  • Offense Report Case #213010749
  • Official Notification of Death
  • Employee Report of Officer Nicholas Reardon
  • Package List
  • Party Details Redacted
  • Pert Phone Records
  • Phone Records Communication
  • Phone Interview with Beautiful Strat'ann
  • Phone Interview with Carrie Davis
  • Phone Interview with Leia Smith
  • Phone Records Review
  • Redactions Made
  • Preservation Letter Email Copy
  • Prosecutor Summary
  • Review of Medical Records
  • RING Correspondence Has Been Received
  • Search Warrant Affidavit for ADT Account
  • Search Warrant Affidavit for RING Account
  • Search Warrant for ADT Account
  • Search Warrant for RING Account
  • T-Mobile Subpoena 614-290-7613
  • T-Mobile Subpoena 614-439-7763
  • T-Mobile Subpoena 614-591-2939
  • T-Mobile Subpoena 614-680-4774
  • T-Mobile Subpoena 614-680-6315
  • Investigative photos

  • Crime scene photos
  • Evidence photos 1
  • Evidence photos 2
  • Evidence photos 3
  • Evidence photos 4
  • Evidence photos 5
  • Evidence photos 6
  • Evidence photos 7
  • Evidence photos 8
  • Evidence photos 9
  • Evidence photos 10
  • Evidence photos 11
  • Evidence photos 12
  • Evidence photos 13
  • Social media photos
  • Investigative videos

    Investigative audios

    Investigative documents

  • 2024-07-17 Case Opening
  • 2024-07-17 Evidence Transport Redacted
  • 2024-07-17 Initial Scene Processing Redacted
  • 2024-07-17 MCSO Use of Force Policy Review
  • 2024-07-18 Autopsy Viewing Redacted
  • 2024-07-18 Witness Interviews Redacted
  • 2024-07-22 Audio interview MCSO CO Sean Barker
  • 2024-07-22 Audio Interview MCSO Director Rebecca Byrne Redacted
  • 2024-07-22 Audio Interview MCSO Jail Inmate Ionut Zaharia
  • 2024-07-22 Video Interview MCSO Sheriff Terry Grice Redacted
  • 2024-07-23 Evidence Submission to OOCIC
  • 2024-07-23 Video Interview Deputy Doug Clinage
  • 2024-07-26 Evidence Return to MCSO
  • 2024-08-06 Interview of Albert Koons Redacted
  • 2024-08-09 MCSO Deputy Piroli BWC Video Review Redacted
  • 2024-08-09 MCSO Deputy Yorks BWC Video Review
  • 2024-08-12 EMS Run Report Redacted
  • 2024-08-12 Evidence Submission
  • 2024-08-15 CCU Analysis Report of Taser Redacted
  • 2024-08-15 Dispatch Information Review Redacted
  • 2024-08-29 MPD Sgt Ory BWC Video Reviews
  • 2024-09-09 Clothing Documentation
  • 2024-09-24 Autopsy Review Report Redacted
  • 2024-09-24 Personnel File Review Redacted
  • 2024-09-25 Evidence Submission Firearms Redacted
  • 2024-09-30 Surveillance Video Review
  • 2024-10-01 Firearms Lab Review Redacted
  • 2024-10-03 Prosecutor Overview Redacted
  • 2024-10-17 File To Prosecutor
  • 2024-10-18 File to Attorney General's Special Prosecutions Office
  • 2024-2096 cyclone report
  • 24-002675 Report Redacted 256375-256987 Redacted
  • 24-002693 Search Warrant Inventory 256374-256986
  • REDACTIONS APPLIED
  • Report of Drone Operation 2096
  • Victoria Carter CFSs Reports Redacted 256373 256985 Redacted
  • Investigative photos

  • Photos 1
  • Photos 2
  • Photos 3
  • Photos 4
  • Photos 5
  • Photos Redacted
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Investigative documents

  • Autopsy Report
  • Cleveland Division of Police audio video analysis unit
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Detail Sheet
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Daryl Johnson
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Prock
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Shane Bauhof
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Shane Bauhof
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Shane Bauhof 2
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Shane Bauhof 3
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det Bauhof 4
  • Cleveland PD Supplemental Report from Det T Manson
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Traffic Crash Report
  • REDACTED CPD Supplemental Report Det David Borden
  • Crime scene entry log
  • Cuyahoga County regional Forensic Science Lab Test Fire Report
  • Cuyahoga County Regional Forensic Science Lab Report
  • Declination of Officer Duncan to make a voluntary statement
  • REDACTED Incident MA 2210109588
  • REDACTED Incident MA 2210109615
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Incident Report 22 10109588
  • REDACTED Miranda Waiver for O F
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Chronological Record Supplemental Report
  • REDACTED Crime scene entry log Supplemental Report
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Investigation Book Table of Contents Supplemental Report
  • REDACTED Cleveland PD Investigation Checklist Supplemental Report
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report Det Christopher Faunce 1
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report Det Christopher Faunce 2
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report from Det Christopher Faunce
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report from Det Christopher Faunce 3
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report from PTL Deondre L Westfield
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report from PTLM Deondre L Westfield
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report from Sgt Deann Frazier
  • REDACTED Maple Heights PD Supplemental Report from Sgt Robert Voll
  • REDACTED NIBIN reports linking gun found to shootings in maple
  • REDACTED Supplement Report from Det Bauhof
  • REDACTED Duncan Additional Police Reports completed
  • REDACTED Duncan Personnel File
  • REDACTED Mijangos Personnel File
  • REDACTED Photos of officers and their service weapon
  • Redactions Made
  • Vehicle Processing Request
  • Vehicle Tow Supplement
  • Investigative photos

  • Digital Photo Evidence 1
  • Digital Photo Evidence 3
  • Digital Photo Evidence 4
  • REDACTED Digital Photo Evidence 2
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Case file regarding the traffic crash that occurred on June 13, 2021 involving Eric Cole and the Springfield Police Division. The investigation was conducted by the Springfield Police Division and the Ohio State Highway Patrol and was presented by an Ohio Attorney General’s Office special prosecutor to a Clark County grand jury on June 7, 2022. The grand jury issued a no-bill indictment in the case, declining to indict the law enforcement officers involved in the case.

    Investigative documents

  • BCI DNA Lab Report on July 22, 2021
  • BCI DNA Lab Report on Sep 29, 2021
  • BCI GSR Lab Report
  • BCI Lab Evidence Submission
  • Case Redactions
  • CCSO Communications
  • Division File of Officer Rosales
  • Toxicology Report
  • Dispatch Incident Recall Report
  • Interview of Officer Emory
  • Interview of Officer Rosales
  • Traffic Crash Report
  • Audit Logs for Interviews
  • Crash Reconstruction Report
  • Radio Log
  • Request Assistance of the Special Prosecutions Section
  • Springfield Police Division Incident Report 21-24387
  • Springfield Police Division Incident Report 21-24736
  • Springfield Police Division Incident Report 21-24737
  • Springfield Police Division Incident Report 21-24738
  • Springfield Police Division Daily Report
  • Investigative photos

  • Incident Number 21-24387
  • Incident Number 21-24736
  • Incident Number 21-24737
  • Incident Number 21-24737 CSI
  • Incident Number 21-24737 CSI2
  • Incident Number 21-24738 A
  • Incident Number 21-24738 B Redacted
  • Incident Number 21-24738 CSI
  • Incident Number 21-24738 CSI2
  • Incident Number 21-24738 CSI3
  • Incident Number 21-24738 CSI4
  • Incident Number 21-24738 CSI5
  • Incident Number 21-24738 Redacted
  • Photos 1
  • Photos 2
  • Photos 3
  • Investigative audios

    Investigative videos

    Large files available upon request

    Copies of surveillance video files are available upon request by emailing Mallory.Naftzger@OhioAGO.gov.