Saturday, February 22, 2025, 2:27AM |  27°
MENU
Advertisement
1
MORE

Hina Naveed: The child welfare system targets the poor

Getty Images/iStockphoto

Hina Naveed: The child welfare system targets the poor

When I graduated from nursing school five years ago, I worked for an agency in New York City’s foster care system. I believed I was helping families. But what I saw there was not a system working for children’s best interests, but one that was quick to separate children from their parents because they were living in poverty.

I’ve since gone to law school and now work as a human rights advocate. For the past year, as a fellow with Human Rights Watch and the American Civil Liberties Union, I have been investigating the system I once worked for — not just in New York, but across the country.

We found that child welfare systems punish families experiencing poverty by removing children and charging parents with “neglect.” Our analysis of nationwide child welfare data showed alarming racial and ethnic disparities. Black and Indigenous families are more likely to be investigated than white families. Single mothers of color are most frequently held responsible for neglect. Parents are often not told their rights or connected with an attorney early enough in the process.

Advertisement

Every year, more than 3 million children are subjected to a child welfare investigation. The process can be highly stressful and traumatic for families. Child welfare authorities may search the family’s home, interrogate neighbors, strip search and question children — sometimes based on anonymous or unfounded accusations.

Firearms are displayed at Smoke N’ Guns on July 9, 2021, in Oakmont.
Colleen O. Fedor
Colleen O. Fedor: Violence traumatizes teens. Here's one answer

Most referrals to the system do not involve abuse. The overwhelming majority of cases, nearly 75% in 2019, include allegations of state-defined neglect, which is inextricably linked to poverty. Parents struggling with limited resources, unable to pay rent or secure stable housing, or working long hours to make ends meet, are judged unfit and neglectful.

As a registered nurse in New York, I was required to report any concerns about child abuse or neglect to the state child protective services hotline, or risk losing my license and facing harsh criminal penalties. Every state has a similar requirement.

But broad and vague state definitions of abuse and neglect mean that teachers, social workers, and health care providers are required to report families out of an abundance of caution, even if our professional training and clinical judgment dictate otherwise.

Advertisement

Millions of reports are made every year, overwhelming an already burdened child welfare system. Most do not warrant an investigation.

We found a clear correlation between child welfare investigations and poverty, as counties with more families living in poverty have higher rates of investigation. Black families, however, experience a high rate of maltreatment investigations even when living in counties where the poverty rate is low.

Black children make up just 14% of the U.S. child population but 24% of child abuse or neglect reports and 21% of children entering the foster system. Indigenous children are also disproportionately affected. They enter the foster system at nearly double the nationwide rate.

I’ve talked to parents who only learned about a child maltreatment allegation against them when a caseworker showed up on their doorstep. Often, the caseworker assigned to reunify a family is also responsible for making the case to terminate parental rights and place a child for adoption.

Michelle Rosenthal, the sister of Cecil and David Rosenthal who were murdered at the Tree of Life shooting speaks during the Eradicate Hate Global Summit at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center downtown Monday, Oct. 18, 2021 in Pittsburgh. (Pam Panchak/Post-Gazette)
Beth Kissileff
Beth Kissileff: Building a society of mutual care and kindness to combat hate and violence

These roles are inherently at odds. Caseworkers tasked with documenting parents’ struggles and shortcomings to build a case against them are, at the same time, expected to somehow support family reunification.

Caseworkers have significant influence in determining whether maltreatment occurred. If a caseworker “substantiates” an allegation, parents or caregivers are listed on a state central maltreatment registry, where they often remain for years, affecting job opportunities and perpetuating the cycle of poverty.

Of course, there are devastating cases where children face serious abuse and intervention is needed. The problem, however, is that the system we have now is not designed to effectively keep children safe. Instead, the system puts parents, especially single mothers of color, in the impossible situation of having to overcome poverty in order to stop being monitored and to reunite with their children, without providing them the resources necessary to do so.

The entire system needs an overhaul. Lawmakers should address the extreme economic hardship and systemic racism at the heart of many child welfare cases. Federal, state and local governments should invest in community resources and support that addresses families’ needs instead of punishing and surveilling them.

Hina Naveed is the Aryeh Neier fellow at Human Rights Watch and the American Civil Liberties Union. This column was produced by Progressive Perspectives, which is run by The Progressive magazine.

First Published: December 5, 2022, 5:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (9)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Mayor Ed Gainey during  a press conference at the Downtown Public Safety Center on Thursday. He angrily criticized what he believes negative media coverage of his work as mayor.
1
opinion
Brandon McGinley: ‘The wheels are coming off’ the Gainey administration
The University of Pittsburgh's Cathedral of Learning
2
business
Amid funding uncertainty, Pitt pauses doctoral admissions
Longtime KDKA-TV host Jon Burnett on May 22, 2019.
3
a&e
Jon Burnett, long a KDKA-TV staple, leaves legacy of ‘putting good out into the world’
Two slices of New York-style pizza and one cut of Sicilian at Etna Slice House in Etna.
4
life
Etna Slice House is 'closed until further notice' following pizzaiolo's departure
The Breezewood Interchange is dotted with gas stations, chain restaurants and souvenir shops. The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission has selected Chicago-based Alfred Benesch and Company to spearhead a major redesign of the notorious roadway.
5
business
So long, Breezewood: Chicago firm selected to redesign infamous Pa. Turnpike interchange
 (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Getty Images/iStockphoto
Advertisement
LATEST opinion
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story